Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake
Independent guide. Not affiliated with Jack in the Box. Prices and availability may vary by location. Please check the official Jack in the Box app or your local restaurant for exact prices.
2026 price and availability are TBD, awaiting the official 2026 announcement. This page is a draft for that update. No 2026 holiday announcement has been found as of October 25, 2026, on jackinthebox.com or its Facebook page. Do not treat the historical prices or nutrition below as 2026 figures.
Instant answer
Do not merge these three versions. 2026 availability and price are still TBD, and the official Shakes page did not list pumpkin on October 25, 2026.
1) Classic Pumpkin Pie Shake, introduced 2004: vanilla ice cream blended with pumpkin pie syrup, topped with whipped topping and a maraschino cherry. Classic 16oz: 808 calories. A 2008 throwback version was blended with a whole slice of pumpkin pie and pie crust.
2) Pumpkin Spice Shake, 2017: real ice cream blended with pumpkin spice syrup, topped with whipped cream and gingersnap cookie crumbles. Regular: 860 calories in that 2017 review.
3) Basic Witch Shake, as named in the AI Overview and social posts: vanilla soft-serve, pumpkin spice syrup, crushed Oreo cookie pieces, whipped cream and a maraschino cherry. It is a seasonal fall and Halloween item, typically early October through mid-to-late November, not year-round. Past pricing, labeled as past AI Overview pricing, not 2026: around $3.99 to $4.69 regular and $5.19 large. This Basic Witch naming is labeled clearly as AI Overview and social naming, not as a confirmed official 2026 announcement.
Direct answer: The Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake is a seasonal holiday shake built on a vanilla ice cream base, topped with whipped topping and a maraschino cherry. It was introduced as Pumpkin Pie in 2004, per a 2008 Jack in the Box announcement, and was historically sold in 16oz and 24oz sizes. For 2026, price and availability are TBD, awaiting the official 2026 announcement.
Price and nutrition at a glance
| Item | Figure | Year and source label |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 price | TBD | 2026, awaiting official announcement |
| 2026 calories, 16oz | TBD | 2026, awaiting official announcement |
| Historical classic price, regular 16oz | $2.49 | Historical, older reports, location-varying |
| Historical classic price, large 24oz | $2.99 | Historical, older reports, location-varying |
| Later local historical prices | $2.69 and $3.29 | Historical, later local reports, location-varying |
| Historical classic nutrition, 16oz | 808 calories, 40g fat, 28g saturated fat, 280mg sodium, 98g carbs, 83g sugar, 12g protein | Historical classic-shake figures, BrandEating, not 2026 figures |
| 2024 Noggy or Nice, a different product, Seattle 2024, regular | $6.29, 800 calories | 2024 only, Seattle 2024 prices |
| 2024 Noggy or Nice, a different product, Seattle 2024, large | $6.79, 1,150 calories | 2024 only, Seattle 2024 prices |
See the site’s Shakes and Desserts section, its Menu Prices page, and its Deals page for related guides. This is an independent guide, not affiliated with Jack in the Box, and prices and availability vary by location.
What is in it
The classic Pumpkin Pie Shake is built on a vanilla ice cream base, with whipped topping and a maraschino cherry, per the 2008 Jack in the Box announcement. It is the holiday pumpkin entry in Jack in the Box’s classic seasonal shake lineup, alongside the Eggnog Shake.
Sizes
The classic shake was historically sold in two sizes: regular 16oz and large 24oz. No 2026 sizes have been announced as of October 25, 2026, so 2026 sizes are TBD.
Calories and nutrition
The historical classic 16oz figures, from BrandEating, are 808 calories, 40g fat, 28g saturated fat, 280mg sodium, 98g carbs, 83g sugar, and 12g protein. These are historical classic-shake figures, not 2026 figures. No 2026 calorie count has been announced, so the 2026 figure is TBD.
Price history vs 2026 TBD
Historically, older reports listed $2.49 for a regular 16oz shake and $2.99 for a large 24oz shake, with prices varying by location. Later local reports listed $2.69 and $3.29. Those are historical, location-varying prices only. The 2026 price is TBD, awaiting the official 2026 announcement, and no 2026 price is claimed in this draft.
When it is usually available
Historically, the Pumpkin Pie Shake is a holiday-season item, associated with the Thanksgiving and Christmas season. That is a historical seasonal pattern only. No 2026 return date has been announced as of October 25, 2026, so do not treat any past seasonal window as a 2026 date.
Classic vs Noggy or Nice Biscoff Shake comparison
The classic Pumpkin Pie Shake and the 2024 Noggy or Nice Sweet Biscoff Shake are different products and must not be conflated. The classic shake is built on a vanilla ice cream base with whipped topping and a maraschino cherry. The 2024 Noggy or Nice Sweet Biscoff Shake is a vanilla shake blended with eggnog flavor and topped with Biscoff crumbs. It was announced November 13, 2024, and was available nationwide through the New Year. Its Seattle 2024 prices were regular $6.29 and 800 calories, and large $6.79 and 1,150 calories. Those 2024 figures are labeled as 2024 only.
Pumpkin Pie vs Egg Nog comparison
Both are classic seasonal shakes with a vanilla ice cream base, whipped topping, and a maraschino cherry, sold historically in 16oz and 24oz sizes. Egg Nog was introduced in 2000 and Pumpkin Pie in 2004, per the 2008 Jack in the Box announcement. Their historical classic 16oz nutrition differs: Pumpkin Pie is listed at 808 calories, 40g fat, 28g saturated fat, 280mg sodium, 98g carbs, 83g sugar, and 12g protein, while Egg Nog is listed at 809 calories, 40g fat, 28g saturated fat, 262mg sodium, 98g carbs, 72g sugar, and 12g protein, from BrandEating. See the companion draft, Jack in the Box Eggnog Shake.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake back in 2026?
No 2026 return has been confirmed. As of October 25, 2026, no 2026 holiday announcement has been found on jackinthebox.com or its Facebook page, so 2026 availability is TBD, awaiting the official 2026 announcement.
How much does the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake cost?
The 2026 price is TBD. Historically, older reports listed $2.49 for regular 16oz and $2.99 for large 24oz, and later local reports listed $2.69 and $3.29, with prices varying by location. Those are historical prices only, not 2026 prices.
How many calories are in the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake?
The 2026 calorie count is TBD. The historical classic 16oz figure, from BrandEating, is 808 calories, with 40g fat, 28g saturated fat, 280mg sodium, 98g carbs, 83g sugar, and 12g protein. That is a historical figure, not a 2026 figure.
What sizes does the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake come in?
Historically, it came in regular 16oz and large 24oz sizes. No 2026 sizes have been announced as of October 25, 2026, so 2026 sizes are TBD.
What is in the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake?
It is built on a vanilla ice cream base, topped with whipped topping and a maraschino cherry, per the 2008 Jack in the Box announcement.
Is the Pumpkin Pie Shake the same as Noggy or Nice?
No. Noggy or Nice Sweet Biscoff Shake is a different 2024 product: a vanilla shake blended with eggnog flavor and topped with Biscoff crumbs, announced November 13, 2024, and available nationwide through the New Year. It is not the classic Pumpkin Pie Shake.
When does the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake come back?
No 2026 return date has been announced. Historically it is a Thanksgiving and Christmas season item, but that historical pattern is not a 2026 date.
Is the Jack in the Box Pumpkin Pie Shake available everywhere?
Availability has historically varied, and prices vary by location. For 2026, availability is TBD, awaiting the official 2026 announcement, so check jackinthebox.com, its Facebook page, or your local restaurant before visiting.
How does the Pumpkin Pie Shake compare with the Eggnog Shake?
Both share the classic vanilla ice cream base, whipped topping, maraschino cherry, and historical 16oz and 24oz sizes, but Egg Nog was introduced in 2000 and Pumpkin Pie in 2004. Historically, Pumpkin Pie 16oz had 83g sugar and 280mg sodium, compared with Egg Nog 16oz at 72g sugar and 262mg sodium, from BrandEating.
Where can I check for the 2026 Pumpkin Pie Shake update?
Check jackinthebox.com and Jack in the Box’s Facebook page for the official 2026 announcement, and check the site’s Deals page for related offers. Until an announcement appears, treat 2026 price and availability as TBD.
Review summary
Summary, not copied review text: BrandEating in 2011 found the classic version pretty easy to drink. The Impulsive Buy review in 2017 found the pumpkin spice version weak in pumpkin spice flavor, with whipped cream not helping, while gingersnap pieces added punch.
Copycat recipe
Copycat recipe, not the official recipe: Combine 3/4 cup whole milk, 3 tablespoons sugar, 3 cups vanilla ice cream, 3/4 cup canned pumpkin, and 3/4 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice, then blend and garnish with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry if desired. This home copycat is the Top Secret Recipes version, and it is not the official Jack in the Box recipe.
Additional frequently asked questions
Does Jack in the Box have pumpkin milkshakes?
Pumpkin shakes at Jack in the Box are seasonal, not year-round. For 2026, availability is TBD, so check the current menu before visiting, and note that the official Shakes page did not list pumpkin on October 25, 2026.
What is the difference between Pumpkin Pie, Pumpkin Spice, and Basic Witch shakes?
They are three different versions, not one item. Classic Pumpkin Pie Shake, introduced 2004, is vanilla ice cream blended with pumpkin pie syrup, topped with whipped topping and a maraschino cherry, with classic 16oz at 808 calories. Pumpkin Spice Shake, 2017, is real ice cream blended with pumpkin spice syrup, topped with whipped cream and gingersnap cookie crumbles, with regular at 860 calories in that 2017 review. Basic Witch Shake, as named in the AI Overview and social posts, is vanilla soft-serve with pumpkin spice syrup, crushed Oreo pieces, whipped cream and a maraschino cherry, a fall and Halloween seasonal item, with past pricing around $3.99 to $4.69 regular and $5.19 large, labeled as past AI Overview pricing, not 2026.
What is the best milkshake at Jack in the Box?
That is subjective, and this draft does not claim a winner. Reviews differ by version: BrandEating in 2011 found the classic version pretty easy to drink, while The Impulsive Buy in 2017 found the pumpkin spice version weak in pumpkin spice flavor, with gingersnap pieces adding punch. Choose by which version and flavor profile you prefer.
Who else has pumpkin shakes?
This draft does not claim a list of other chains with pumpkin shakes. Check that chain’s current seasonal menu before assuming a pumpkin shake is available there.
Is the Oreo Shake the same as the Basic Witch Shake?
No. The Oreo Shake is a separate year-round shake on the official list, while the Basic Witch Shake uses Oreo pieces as a mix-in. They are not the same item.
